I will attempt to keep the spoilers to a minimum but consider this fair warning.
I came into this film with two frames of mind. First, I have waited my entire life (five decades-plus) to see a good Justice League film. I am a child of the Silver Age of comics and everyone has wanted to see all of the DC heroes on the screen at once. It was going to be hard for any film to live up to a lifetime of internal hype and hope.
My second mindset was that I dislike the whole Zack Synder take on the DC universe. I didn’t love Man of Steel and it took a few viewings of Batman vs Superman to fully appreciate it.
So that I had perspective, I viewed the film with my daughter and grandson who also had a lifetime of waiting to see these characters on the screen. Three generations of us, mentally braced with the acceptance that we may not like it.
We loved it. We really did. I know that will make some fanboys whine, but all that matters is that we enjoyed the film. Heck, I might go again.
The things that made this movie good was a relatively simple plot (one of the many failings in Batman vs Superman). The story was simple. The heroes were true to form and everyone got good airtime. I think that Ben Affleck is outstanding as Batman – perhaps one of the best casting decisions ever. Gal Gadot IS Wonder Woman.
Things I enjoyed:
- They made Aquaman cool. It’s hard to believe, but true.
- The movie didn’t dwell on origin stories so that the pacing was good.
- The interplay between Batman and Wonder Woman was good, very true to their characters.
- There were moments of humor that were unexpected and good – like Aquaman sitting on the lasso of truth.
- Nothing beat that moment when the Flash was running past Superman and the Supes turned and tracked him. Yeah, he’s that fast Barry.
- The post credit scenes honored us Silver Age/Silver Hair crowd and took us in a new direction other than some grim Darkseid plotline which seemed to be the previous course. The first post-credits scene made the movie for me, the icing on the cake.
- Superman smiled and even laughed. Gone was Syderian-era of the grim and brooding Man of Steel.
Things I’m on the fence about:
- Steppenwolf. I’ve been reading comics for a long time and I didn’t recognize this villain – which was embarrassing. You would have thought that with the pantheon of characters, they could have come up with someone more recognizable to the masses.
- This was not the Barry Allen or the Flash I knew or wanted to see in film. Don’t get me wrong, he worked perfectly as a comic relief in the film, fitting into the ensemble well, but he wasn’t quite the Flash I had been hoping for. I was torn between my expectations for the character and how well he was portrayed in the film. I didn’t hate this Flash, but I didn’t love him.
- The producers seem unconcerned with the fact that most of these characters have their secret identities compromised. Even Lois yelling, “Clark!” to Superman with the police on the ground seemed a little weird. Perhaps that is all intentional…hmm…
So, is it worth seeing? Yes! Who would have thought that 2017 would have given us two great DC films? Perhaps this is a sign of things to come.