A friend of mine recommended I watch this series about the disappearance of this young three-year-old in Portugal in 2007. I have to admit, I went in with prejudice. Like most of us, I was fed a steady stream of news reports about Madeleine’s disappearance and it felt to me like the parents were somehow involved.
The series reduced that feeling, but there are some things that still don’t add up for me. The fact that the series made me question my preconceived notion is a good sign.
The series is, well, slow. It is plodding along, without a sense of tempo or care for the audience. Having said that, I think it does a very good job of layout out the events. There are a lot of blind allies the producers take you down. The whole human trafficking angle is intriguing, but at the same time, lacks any substance…at least from what I saw. Theories are thrown at the wall to see what will stick, which is not a good approach to such a series.
Adding to this were the cast of characters that latched onto the case. Psychics, dog handlers, private investigators…some seeming to insert themselves into the case for the publicity. It is a cautionary tale for anyone that loses a loved one in the same manner…be wary of the company you keep.
The authorities were in over their heads from the start of the case. They fingered people, for legitimate reasons in their minds, but mismanaged every aspect of the investigation. There is a bombshell (of sorts) about the lead investigator that pops in the middle of the series, something that I was surprised about.
Did I soften my feeling about the parents as suspects? Yes. But some of their actions still raise big eyebrows for me. Their attempt to get their dinner guests to align on their stories, for example, made little sense. As a parent, I wouldn’t have left my kids in that situation – but I am also not from their culture nor was I there. Seeds of doubt remain with me.
I give this about a 3.5 out of 5 stars. It could have been reduced to three or four episodes easily, and would have been more enjoyable. The constant drone shots of the beach and the city made this far too many episodes long.