Hour of the Wolf Part IV – The Fan Theories

If not Clan Wolverine – where is Clan Stoned Pony?

Hour of the Wolf is a big deal, I get that. Speculation was running high prior to the book’s release. I got bombarded with them constantly – every crazed idea ow concept conceived in fan-fictional delusion.  Even when I said “Hell no!” to some fan idea, they thought I was misdirecting them from the truth.  

Most of these were wishful thinking…if you put it out there enough on the web, it might happen…your favorite faction will rise to power.  Some of these are clearly the products of heavy drug use or deep-seated mental problems.  Please people, see your doctors, take your meds.  This is the voice of experience telling you this (I suffer from depression and am medicated for it.)

In writing, you have to be careful about using a deus ex machina intervention.  As I have come to learn, there is a difference between suspense and surprise.  Suspense is knowing that the Dragoons and Anastasia Kerensky are on Terra, and you wondering when they are going to join the fight.  Surprise is when suddenly, without any build up, you drop in some faction or hero to resolve a problem in the story.  Suspense is good.  Surprise must be done well, and in HotW, it wouldn’t have played out well.  You can’t drop a lot of big surprise moments – and we saved ours for the last chapter.    

I thought it might be fun to take a look at the theories I encountered.  Sit back, put on your foil-hats…it’s about to get bumpy. 

The Wolverines will sweep in and become the ilClan.  We had a huge build-up to HotW in terms of fiction.  Things were on the table. Only once was Clan Wolverine referenced…and then just in passing in Children of Kerensky. Regardless, the die-hard Wolverineeies swore this mysterious force was going to jump in on Terra and save the day.  It would have been a pure deus ex machina move, and would have been horrible writing.  “Surprise – some group you have not had a connection with in ages is now in charge!”  Ugh!  It is bad storytelling to drop a bomb like that without some hint of it coming. As much as I protested it, fans still believed it was going to happen.  Yeah, I know, 9-11 was fake too…blah, blah, blah, you guys crack me up. Some pointed to the Kickstarter fiction piece a wrote, Redemption and Malice as ‘ironclad evidence’ that the Wolverines were going to show up in HotW. The piece never directly mentions the Wolverines at all.  It was hardly a prelude to something this big.  Geez!   

The Ghost Bears would become the ilClan.  Granted, we saw actual Ghost Bears in the fiction leading up to this, but never once got an inkling that they were going to save the Republic’s ass or seize the Star League throne for themselves.  People make big mistakes about the Clans.  They assume everyone in a Clan thinks, acts, and believes exactly the same things.  As much as we showed division in both Clans Wolf and Jade Falcon, everyone just presumes that all of the Ghost Bears would be hot-to-trot to get to Terra.  My friends, if you believed this, you know NOTHING about Clan Ghost Bear.  We hammered this out carefully and methodically in the writer’s summit.  This isn’t just a Blaine-thing, it is a “So say we all,” thing. 

But I did give you a cool Ghost Bear turned Wolf character in the War Bear. So technically, I may have inadvertently planted the seed on this theory. My bad!

The Smoke Jaguars would become the ilClan.  I won’t lie and say I didn’t mull over this one, despite the fact that the Wolves were preordained to be the ilClan.  After all, we had a lot of buildup of the Jags.  Having them be the ilClan made zero sense however. This was not their destiny – as was stated in Children of Kerensky.  Still, the Jag-fan-bois clung to that forlorn hope.  I think we are going to get better stories out of that Clan based on how they are positioned now.  They are on their way back – and that makes them interesting and fertile for great storytelling to come.

The Republic was going to survive in some form.  From the moment I was brought in on this at GenCon 2017 I maintained one thing – for the Dark Ages to die, the Republic had to go.  I never wavered from that, nor did CGL. The Republic represented the Dark Ages.  Alaric would not allow them to exist. It would have been out of character for him to do so. Yes, it is rare that a faction is truly gone in BattleTech but this was needed for the emotional and symbolic break with an era.   

I would bring back the Word of Blake and somehow they would factor into the new era.  People, I have never been that drunk and I have consumed a lot of alcohol over the years. 

Stone is actually Arthur Steiner-Davion.  Don’t you think that Victor might have noticed that?  If you harbored this thought it is time for you to pee in a cup and get a test.  And, if memory serves, Arthur’s fate has already been covered in sourcebook material. 

The Cameron line would be restored.  Corollary theory:  Stone is a Cameron and will rule the new Star League.  In 1992 I wrote the ComStar Sourcebook and referenced the Tripitz affair.  In Shrapnel, a fiction piece was written around a conspiracy theory (here’s your first clue that this isn’t going to pan out) about a surviving pair of Cameron’s, leveraging the 1992 piece as its basis. I feel pretty secure in saying that if we were going down that path, Shrapnel would probably not been the launching point.  I’m not saying it’s not a cool idea, but there would need to be a hell of a lot of build-up for something like this. 

Also, if Stone was a Cameron, why would he have kept that a secret?  Do you know the man’s ego?  He would have played that card every chance he got.  It’s like a pickup line at a bar.  “Hey babe, wanna hook up with a Cameron-heir?” 

Clan Jade Falcon for the win! Hold it right there cowboy! I’m not your Huckleberry on this one. A case can be made that if the Falcons won, we would get some fascinating stories out of it as everyone in the Inner Sphere rallied against them. I keep thinking of last week’s Wandavision episode with a twist, “It was Malvina all along!” When you write fiction like this, a spine novel, you want to lay the foundation for good stories. We needed to get away from characters that were cut-and-dry good or bad. Malvina winning would have been scary, but won’t give us the depth we can get from the Wolves being the ilClan. Besides, the Jade Falcons have the potential of being the coolist of the Clans going forward.

Stone and Alaric would battle for control of Terra in some sort of trial and end up jointly ruling Terra.  I guess this came from that infamous Ben Rome document floating out in dark corners of the web. I didn’t track down that document until long after the book was written.  Thank God we didn’t follow that outline. I tried to write up Stone and Alaric fighting it out in the first draft, but in all honesty, it sucked. As far as ideas went, the thought that Stone would beat Alaric in a Trial was borderline unbelievable from the start. He’s an antique and Alaric is in his prime.  Stone hadn’t piloted a ‘Mech in a LONG time.

Wolves Dragoons might take Terra and become the ilClan.  Okay, I like this one because it was possible-ish, under the right circumstances.  Its only weakness is that it destroys the cool factor of the Dragoons; that they are mercenaries.  While it could have been entertaining, can you image the people’s reaction who believe that the Dragoons are already Mary Sue’s?  “Oh sure, now they control Terra!  WTF?”

The Wolves in Exile would be the ilClan.  Um, how?  With one galaxy of force, how could they have possibly pulled that off?  No, that was not an invitation for you to explain your theory in-depth to me. 

Clan Snow Raven for the win! Really?  This story was one that was built up in a series of novellas and books prior to the big show.  At no point was there a hint of the Snow Ravens plotting to come in, yet a handful of dedicated fans entrenched with this theory.  I did give the Snow Ravens their best character in a long time in Haake though.

The Homeworld Clans would sweep in and take Terra.  Let’s talk logistics.  It is a LONG way to Clan Space.  They have no idea what is going on in the Inner Sphere.  In fact, they pretty much nuked themselves back to the Stone Age during the Wars of Reaving. We saw no hint of them in the prelude work – but some fans swore they were going to come charging in. 

So, did I miss any?

21 thoughts on “Hour of the Wolf Part IV – The Fan Theories

  1. madvaca

    I’m proud to admit I’ve at least played devil’s advocate for all of these over the years. I still think Wolverine & Cameron will get some future plotlines but they’re unlikely to come out ahead on them. Certainly not on top.

    In the meantime time I’ll just sit here and enjoy the amazing potential Hour opens up for the universe. Especially since the 3250 peek makes the Falcon OZ look like Chaos March 2.0

  2. Steve Restless

    The absolute refusal to believe it could possibly be clan Wolf who becomes ilClan, and desperate grasping at every possible other straw was one of the most frustrating parts of getting to this point.

  3. Steven

    I thought that Stone and friends would help out the Suns by staging a false flag against the Bears, with them sneaking a nuke onto their newly built Leviathan III class battleship and then pinning the blame on the Combine. This would make the Bears go ARGLE BARGLE!!!! and then basically do this on Combine worlds – https://i.imgur.com/oqVwBTp.gif and this would help the suns.

    I also assumed that during the Battle for Terra, the Wolves and Republic would fight together against the Falcons due to the sheer bad end that would happen if Malvina got to be ilKhan of the ilClan. I thought that she’d start loosing and would then do a ‘If I can’t have it, then no one shall’ and order her surviving WarShips to indescriminately bombard Terra. It was at this point that the chekov’s gun of her ‘pet’ and her knife would be fired, or some more moderate Jade Falcon would kill her with the surviving and badly mauled Falcons calling for higara. (Meanwhile the near undefended Falcon OZ’s being rapidly gobbled up by the Hell’s Horses and the Lyran’s who are desperate to get the Falcons away from their Capital.

  4. scott bier

    Was happy that I didnt have any of these ideas. Everything from when the clans first showed up, everything was wolf, wolf, wolf.. and yet more wolf. Also since both Clan Wolf and (Clan) Wolf’s Dragoons.. also had the name Kerensky, it was like WTF? What is the big hold up.. come on already? Its been what how many years… the 3050 read out was published n 1989, HoTW came out in 2021.. over three decades we have waited for Clan Wolf to get it together. Finally ITS DONE!!!

    1. Brandon Woodhouse

      Overall, the Hour of the Wolf was a fitting end for the Dark Age era. I think a lot of the dark age stories that were written led one in a lot of different directions. It wasn’t quite clear where this was going to end up. I know there’s a lot of behind-the-scenes work that goes into this, and I appreciate all the authors that have done so. Without stories BattleTech is just big robots shooting at one another. In and of itself, that is pretty cool, but stories bring it to life and help it continues beyond just the battle. Honestly, it seems that there may have been some cleanup that had to be done from where the last batch of dark age stories left off before they went out of print. I love intrigue, especially in stories in the BattleTech universe. I was mesmerized behind all the information they had been collected on who had caused Gray Monday. I’ve also always been curious as I think the Word of Blake was a brilliant faction that brought chaos and upset the narrative in BattleTech, not to mention by bringing in the Manei Domini it opened up a whole new avenue into the universe. Lastly, all of their forces were never accounted for and they did have lots of secrets. I had long personally speculated they may be behind some of the events of the dark age, especially as how some of the prior fiction had hinted at that. Stones reveal that they were behind Gray Monday was closure on that. Overall, I am excited as to where this book took us and what the future holds! Thank you for the stories!

  5. Steven Cross

    I had a few thoughts.

    1 – That Stone and co would sneak a nuke onto the Ghost Bear’s newest Leviathan III WarShip and pin the blame on the Combine. The Bears then go ARGLE BARGLE and do this – i.imgur.com/oqVwBTp.gif to Combine worlds, helping the Suns and keeping the combine away from the border.

    2 – That the Republic and Alaric would fight together to defeat the Falcons, and that with her forces being pushed back, Malvina orders a mass bombardment of Terra to ‘break the defenders will’. Its at this point that the Chekov’s gun of her ‘pet’ and her knife gets fired or she gets killed by a less insane follower.

    3 – I thought the Falcons would get off world but find their holdings being gobbled up by the Lyrans and Hells Horses and the few remaining Falcons either die defending those worlds or get absorbed by the wolves.

  6. Rob C.

    I hope the remaining Fidelis (who didn’t go Clan Smoke Jaguar), manage keep going. I loved them since the old Surrender Your Dreams, but i worried their uniqiness was lost by the time Hour of the Wolf happened. I guess we need some fiction see the Jaguars have anything like the Fidelis. I know their same people, but their behavior in the Surrender was bit anti-clan in sense to me.

  7. Anthony Hicks

    Started out a massive Wolf fans when I first started with BT. It was going to be them all along and that is how you bring so many other interesting side stories into play. that said I always had a soft spot for Ragnar since his time on Outreach with the rest of the spoiled brats. When he made his way to the Bears it just made sense. Hence, why the Bears are my favorite right now and the Wolves a close second. Love the way that WIE was brought back in too.

    Hoping to see just how the new political side of the clans under an ILClan will play out and yes, the route the Falcons can take now could be a thing of beauty. Jags too for that matter.

    Best part of all…..the WARBEAR!!!!! Beside the tankers, truly my favorite character!

      1. Anthony Hicks

        “Roar” is one of my favorite books of all the off the main spine books!!! I couldn’t put that thing down, Called off of work to finish it off if you can believe that. Should be fun to see the rest of the IS nations find out what a united multiple clan force can do. Watch out Liao, lol.

        Wolves, Falcons, Jags, GB’s and Ravens all on the same page for the most part…..you are really going to have fun writing the next few years. I’m simply happy that BT is going through a very nice recovery the last few years……..and it all starts with the novels.


  8. Andreas

    Well, your comment about the Home Clans makes me wonder. Given WoR they did not nuke themselves back to Stone Age, they did not even use nukes in their fighting given the sourcebook. So is that comment somewhat of a retcon to come?
    Or was that simply a snarky comment, do not dare to disturb with some theories or info fishing about them?

  9. Daniel N

    Having been CJF die hard it’s been a long (and often book throwing bitter) road to arrive at a place of acceptance about post invasion fiction (probably somewhat equivalent to those who would have lived through it). CJF got really dark but the more I’ve thought about it that still has a lot of depth to it.. I’m not sure I agree that the Wolves have greater depth. In fact, I’m sure I don’t, but alas, perhaps I have just developed fictional stockholm syndrome about the whole ordeal. Malvina is dead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s